Should the DCI/SMPTE 431 digital cinema standards be updated for RGB LASER projectors?
Higher contrast ratio
The SMPTE RP 431-2:2011 digital cinema standard document describes the reference projector viewing environments used in DCI digital cinemas.
–SMPTE 431 Review room 14 fL, 100:1 Intra frame contrast, 1500:1 Sequential contrast
–SMPTE 431 Cinema Theatre 14 fL, 100:1 Intra frame contrast, 1200:1 Sequential contrast
When upgrading to RGB LASER projection the contrast ratio will improve.
Most cinemas will see a great improvement of contrast ratio and light levels with an upgrade to RGB Laser projectors.
This improvement will be noticeable on the DCPs used today.
Rec 2020 color space
New digital cinema projectors uses red, green and blue lasers as their light sources. They can reach (almost) the REC 2020 color space.
The RGB laser projectors also have much better contrast ratio and can reach higher light levels without ruining the black level.
The DCI-P3 color space and 1200:1 contrast ratio in SMPTE RP 431-2 are based on what you can achieve with a Xenon lamp projector.
REC2020 covers 99.9 percent of pointer’s gamut, while DCI-P3 cover 91.4 percent. Source
It would be difficult to use an automatic algorithm to map some of these colors to DCI-P3 without changing the artistic expression of the film.
The Alexa SXT camera can record in REC2020
This means that REC 2020 can do all the primary saturated colors, while DCI-P3 is much more limited. DCI-P3 lacks Cyan.
Cinemas is also limited to colors that can be achieved with 14 fL.
Barco White paper “What are ‘better pixels’?”
This Barco white paper from 1. february 2016 looks at REC.2020 and higher contrast ratio in cinemas with RGB laser projectors. They also recommend keeping the optical light path clean.
In practice, it turns out that some effort in reducing the auditorium reflectivity and lens glare (by e.g. keeping the lens and port hole clean of dust) can yield the same or better results than moving to HDR projection.
Dolby Vision and Imax Digital
You can watch RGB laser projection with (almost) REC 2020 color space and higher contrast ratios in Dolby Vision and IMAX Laser cinemas.
These cinemas can reach higher light levels and use bright colors that is not possible in ordinary cinemas.
Read a review of both here.
A LASER IMAX system demonstration used an intra frame contrast checkerboard test image to show the intra frame contrast of their dual LASER projectors. They said in the demonstration that they changed the furnishing and changed the screen to get better contrast ratio.
Consumer products with P3 color space
Televisions UHD Alliance Premium requirements:
Image Resolution: 3840×2160
Color Bit Depth: 10-bit signal
Color Palette (Wide Color Gamut)
Signal Input: BT.2020 color representation
Display Reproduction: More than 90% of P3 colors
High Dynamic Range
SMPTE ST2084 EOTF
A combination of peak brightness and black level either:
More than 1000 nits peak brightness and less than 0.05 nits black level
More than 540 nits peak brightness and less than 0.0005 nits black level
Apple is moving prosumer displays to the DCI-P3 color space. The first product is the Ipad Pro. Source wikipedia.
Dual inventory of DCPs?
I think you can have two kinds of DCPs until all cinemas get RGB Laser or similar projectors:
RP 431-2:2011 DCPs for Xenon/UHP and Phosphor Laser projectors
RP 431-2:RGBLASER DCPs for RGB Laser projectors.
Dual inventory of DCPs is not a big problem.
DCP delivery services that uses fast internet to distribute DCPs to cinemas send the ATMOS DCP to the ATMOS cinemas and 7.1 DCP to the 7.1 cinemas. In the future if a venue have a RGB laser projector, it would be easy to send them the RGB laser DCP instead of the xenon DCP.
RP 431-2:RGB LASER REC 2020 could possibly use:
-REC 2020 color space,
-and higher contrast ratio
inside the 12 bit 2.6 gamma X`Y`Z` JPEG 2000 250 mbit encoding used in today’s DCPs.
Or use the SMPTE ST2084 EOTF standard to be able to use higher light levels.
Upgrading the light path
Changing screen and furnishing to get good intra frame contrast is essential to good projection.
I discussed this in this post:
SOME DIGITAL CINEMA PROJECTION BEST COMMON PRACTICES:
If the intra frame contrast is bad you could try to:
– Clean the port glass and optics.
– Avoid spill light from projection booth.
– Use matte black seats and furnishing.
– Install an iris in the projector.
– Upgrade to a laser projector.
A laser projector will be better at reaching today´s 3D light levels with just one projector and better at reaching today’s standard contrast ratio. 6P Laser projectors can use 3D with matte white screens and one projector.
A new RGB Laser standard could keep today’s light levels and contrast ratios and just add REC2020 color space. Or the standard could go beyond today’s values. RGB Laser projectors could manage higher values. But in a dark viewing environment higher luminance values can seem very bright.
The higher contrast ratio you could get with a laser projector could be ruined by reflective furnishing in the auditorium and other factors like old silver screens.
There should be a certification that cinemas could get to show that they are RP 431-2:2011(Xenon) or (future) RP 431-2:RGBLASER certified and have the correct intra frame contrast ratio and light levels.
Or they could get a certification that say they reach the correct light levels in 2D and 3D. (Xenon projectors cinemas need to be able to reach these levels also when the lamp gets older.)
This way the public would know that kind of cinemas they can choose between.